Last week, I stumbled on a very mediocre sitcom while casually flipping through channels, looking for something good (or just okay) to watch. I was surprised (or should I rather say upset) to see that this unfunny, unoriginal, lame show was still on the air while so many better sitcoms or dramas had been cancelled and forgotten. I know there’s no accounting for taste, but still …
The point I’m trying to make is that I’ve seen a LOT of TV shows in my time, all ranging between life-changing to downright awful. Somewhere in that array, is a special selection of series that were a lot better than the ratings let on. They deserved more appreciation and must not be forgotten. Or at least, deserved more chance. It’s always baffled me why so many subpar shows live on for years on end, while much better ones just get tossed aside in a heartbeat. The titles in this article are some of what I consider the most underappreciated TV shows ever. Of course, there are many, many more, but these are my personal favorites.
DEAD LIKE ME (2003 - 2004)
I stumbled on Dead Like Me by pure accident. I just turned the television on, and there’s this show that’s about to premiere. Back then, I was very much aware of upcoming TV shows; I had a pretty elaborate calendar of what’s airing, where and when. Yet, I never heard of Dead Like Me. Seemed like it appeared without any promo. As soon as it aired, I immediately fell in love with it. As an antisocial (or is it socially awkward? or is it both?), I tend to identify with such characters. And George Lass is just that: a socially awkward girl who’s trying to figure out how she fits in this strange and hard to understand world. She dies in the first episode. Not much of a spoiler here, that’s the premise of the show. As the space station Mir was reentering Earth, it was fast disintegrating and its toilet seat broke off to fall directly on George, killing her instantly. First blow, she realizes that she’s dead. Second blow, some stranger (played by the amazing Mandy Patinkin), the only person on site who can actually see her, announces to her that she is now a grim reaper (the grim reaper who took her soul before she’s killed reached his quota and finally got a promotion). Then she learns that even dead, she must find work to be able to find a place to live and pay the bills. This is an exceptional show about family tensions, work place dynamics and basic human interactions, but with a morbid twist. Bryan Fuller left after the first season and, because of that, the second season wasn’t as tight as the first, but still, Dead Like Me deserved more viewership.
WONDERFALLS (2004)
Also created by Bryan Fuller and starring Caroline Dhavernas, this short-lived series is about an unambitious college graduate who works at a souvenir shop next to Niagara Falls. Her life is turned upside down when objects around her start interacting and talking to her and giving her orders, forcing her to meddle into other people’s lives for reasons she does not understand. This show was so original and witty that I have a hard time understanding why it only lasted one season! Upon some research, I quickly learnt that Fox did not give Wonderfalls any chance to succeed by not promoting the show at all and giving it horrible and always changing time slots. It’s a real shame because Wonderfalls, in all its perkiness and humanity, deserved an audience. Bryan Fuller went on and created another dramatic comedy in 2007, Pushing Daisies, which was very similar to Dead Like Me and Wonderfalls in its colorful style, but unlike its predecessors, Pushing Daisies was actually a success. Though it was fine a show, I always felt like Dead Like Me and Wonderfalls were much better. But despite its success (12 Emmy nominations), Pushing Daisies was cancelled after its second season.
RAISING HOPE (2011 - 2014)
I always felt like Raising Hope did not get the praise it deserved. It was there but no one was talking about it and as soon as it stopped airing, everybody forgot about it. It’s a shame because they succeeded at making a very funny and authentic family sitcom, which is hard to do considering the amount of family sitcoms that are made every year. Raising Hope is among the few recent sitcoms that’s made me laugh out loud; it produced some hilarious moments, played by a perfectly cast set of actors (Martha Plimpton, Garret Dillahunt and Cloris Leachman among others). If you get a chance to watch this show, please do and you will not be disappointed. It’s essentially about Jimmy, a clueless 23 year-old who lives with his parents and grandmother, who suddenly becomes the father of a small baby girl (the mother was arrested after their one-night stand, gave birth to the baby in prison and is on death row).
HOMICIDE : LIFE ON THE STREET (1993 - 1999)
If you asked people to name great cop shows, they will mention NYPD Blues, Law&Order, The Wire, but one thing’s for sure is that no one will say Homicide: Life on the street. Strange thing is, most TV fans or cop show fans I talk to don’t even know about it! Though it ran for 6 seasons and was critically acclaimed, Homicide always suffered from low ratings. I never understood why so many bad cop shows went on to become fan favorites while a riveting and raw procedural like Homicide just sunk into oblivion. I think it’s by far one of the most underappreciated show of all time. Real and realistic, intense, gritty and just riveting to watch, Homicide had it all: complex characters, convoluted story arches, captivating interrogations and most importantly, detectives Bayliss and Pembleton, the greatest yet most complicated duo of all police procedural. Like Wonderfall, Homicide suffered from bad promo from its network and an ever changing time slot that might have prevented it from maintaining a proper fanbase.
CARNIVÀLE (2003 - 2005)
Carnivàle was a bit ahead of its time. Had it aired some time around now, it would have been a huge hit, but back then, people seemed to be more into reality TV and lighter-themed programs. This is very frustrating because Carnivàle was one hell of a show. Set during the Great Depression, this supernatural drama is about an impending battle between what must be assumed to be good and evil, with a travelling carnival caught in the middle of it. Different, original, visually stunning and unnerving, Carnivàle deserved a much better fate. While it was considered too weird and slow-paced back then, it would have been called a masterpiece now… And though it won a few Emmys, the series was cancelled after the second season due to low ratings.
MillenniuM (1996 - 1999)
MillenniuM is a thriller with supernatural undertones, much like The X-Files (both shows were created by Chris Carter). The series follows the investigations of Frank Black, a retired FBI agent turned consultant who is gifted with the ability to see inside criminals’ minds. He also works for a mysterious society called MillenniuM Group, whose involvement in world affairs are somewhat murky. Though captivating to watch, the show was met with mixed reviews; viewers and critics alike found the story lines too macabre and thought they could be lighter and more fun, which is just ridiculous. The darker tone of the episodes, the creepy murders and Frank Black’s haunting visions are what made MillenniuM so great. Once again, had it aired more recently, in the era of everything-must-be dark, MillenniuM would have been a great success.
BETTER OFF TED (2009 - 2010)
Better Off Ted is another show that was met with a lot of critical acclaim but failed to pan out in the ratings. Its main character, Ted, is the head of the Research and Development department of Veridian Dynamics, a powerful, soulless and dehumanizing conglomerate that is willing do whatever it takes for a profit, even if that meant weaponizing everything and anything, testing on its employees, or creating weird things like killer pandas. This entertaining and original sitcom was cancelled and forgotten about after just two seasons despite receiving a lot of positive reviews by critics. The network didn’t even bother to air the last 2 episodes.
PEOPLE OF EARTH (2016 - 2017)
People of Earth is so good and so special. I sincerely do not understand how or why more people are not watching it! Because of that, this hilarious sitcom was cancelled after just two seasons. Half the show takes place on Earth, in a small town called Beacon. A journalist is writing a report about Starcrossed, a support group for experiencers (a.k.a. abductees but they don’t like that term) only to realize that he might have been one as well. Together, they share their experiences and try to figure out the reasons behind these encounters. The other half of the show takes place in the alien spaceship that’s doing the abductions. Three aliens, each of a different species, work together to abduct and test their human subjects. People of Earth is part The X-Files, part The Office and it is genius! Its two seasons were fantastic and it came as a considerable surprise to learn that People of Earth was not renewed for a third season. A great shame!
If you have the opportunity to watch any of the shows listed above, please do and you will surely have a great time. They are far from being masterpieces but they did go out of their way to be bold and different, and for that reason alone, they deserve more appreciation.